What Happens If a Pedestrian Caused an Accident

What Happens If a Pedestrian Caused an Accident?

In recent years, the United States has witnessed a worrying rise in pedestrian fatalities and injuries due to traffic accidents, with a significant 12.5% increase in pedestrian fatalities from 2020, culminating in 7,388 pedestrians killed in 2021. This surge emphasizes the critical question of what happens if a pedestrian causes an accident. The prevalence of pedestrian accidents in urban areas, where 84% of fatalities occurred in 2021, combined with the stark reality that a pedestrian was killed every 71 minutes in traffic crashes that year, has led to a pressing need for awareness and solutions to tackle this issue.

Understanding liability in scenarios where pedestrians may be at fault forms the foundation of legal and financial implications for those involved. The roles that pedestrian accident lawyers and attorneys play in navigating the complexities of pedestrian accident claims, especially in cases of a car hitting a pedestrian or a pedestrian hit by a car, highlight the nuanced nature of determining fault and liability. This article aims to dissect the various scenarios leading to such accidents, delve into the process of determining fault, and explore the comparative negligence principles that could influence the outcome of pedestrian accident claims and legal proceedings.

Understanding Pedestrian and Driver Responsibilities

In the intricate dance of road safety, both pedestrians and drivers play crucial roles, each bearing responsibility to prevent accidents. Understanding these duties is vital for maintaining harmony on the streets.

Driver Responsibilities:

  • Watchfulness: Drivers must remain vigilant for pedestrians at all times, especially when turning at intersections or entering/exiting parking lots.
  • Yielding: Drivers must yield to pedestrians at crosswalks, both signalized and non-signalized, and traffic lights.
  • Speed Control: Approaching crosswalks or intersections requires drivers to slow down and be prepared for sudden pedestrian movements.
  • Distraction Avoidance: Mobile phone use or other distractions are a no-go, as they significantly impair a driver’s ability to notice and react to pedestrians.

Pedestrian Responsibilities:

  • Visibility: Wearing bright or reflective clothing ensures drivers can see pedestrians, crucial during night or low-light conditions.
  • Crossing Safely: Pedestrians should cross roads only at designated crosswalks, following the “look left-right-left” rule and ensuring there’s a safe gap in traffic.
  • Following Traffic Signals: Adhering to traffic lights and signals, and ensuring not to suddenly step into the road, helps prevent unexpected incidents.

Both parties must exercise reasonable caution and adhere to these guidelines to ensure safety for all road users. The emphasis on shared responsibility underlines the importance of cooperation in reducing pedestrian accidents.

Scenarios Where Pedestrians May Be At Fault

Pedestrians, like drivers, have a set of responsibilities to ensure safety on the roads. However, certain risky behaviors can lead to situations where pedestrians may be at fault for accidents. These behaviors include:

  • Jaywalking and Ignoring Traffic Signals: Crossing streets away from designated crosswalks or against traffic signals increases the risk of accidents. Pedestrians should always cross at marked crosswalks and obey pedestrian signals.
  • Impairment from Alcohol or Drugs: Impaired walking, similar to impaired driving, can lead to dangerous situations. Pedestrians under the influence may stumble into the road unexpectedly, posing a risk to themselves and drivers.
  • Distraction and Inattention: With the prevalence of smartphones, distracted walking has become a significant issue. Texting, browsing, or listening to music can divert a pedestrian’s attention from the road, leading to unsafe crossings or walking into traffic without noticing.

Furthermore, darting into traffic, wearing dark clothing at night without reflective materials, and failing to yield the right of way are scenarios that can place pedestrians at fault. Pedestrians causing multi-vehicle accidents due to such behaviors may be held liable for the resulting damages. Pedestrians must be aware of their surroundings, follow traffic laws, and engage in safe behaviors to minimize the risk of accidents.

Determining Fault and Liability

Determining fault and liability in pedestrian accidents involves a multi-step process, often starting with an initial investigation by police officers. They document visible evidence and assess if any laws were violated, making the police report a critical document in the claims process. Following this, the driver’s auto insurer conducts its own investigation to make a liability decision, which the injured pedestrian and their attorney can challenge if deemed unreasonable. Key factors in this assessment include:

  • Point of Impact & Vehicle Speed: Where the collision occurred and how fast the car was moving can indicate fault.
  • Traffic Law Violations: Any breach of traffic laws by the driver or pedestrian plays a crucial role.
  • Visibility Conditions & Evasive Maneuvers: Poor visibility or efforts by the driver to avoid the collision are considered.

Insurance companies delve into these aspects to assign relative liability. However, proving fault extends beyond these initial evaluations. Gathering witness testimonies, reviewing camera footage, and examining the accident scene for physical evidence like skid marks are vital steps. An experienced attorney can navigate through this complex information, challenging any unfair liability determinations by reviewing the police report for inaccuracies and advocating on behalf of the injured pedestrian. They also guide the injured party through documenting all related expenses and losses to build a strong compensation claim.

Comparative Negligence in Pedestrian Accidents

Comparative negligence plays a pivotal role in pedestrian accidents, determining the extent to which each party involved shares fault and how damages are awarded. This legal principle is applied differently across states, affecting the outcome of pedestrian accident claims. Here’s a closer look at how comparative negligence functions in various jurisdictions:

  • Michigan’s Modified Comparative Negligence:
    • If the pedestrian is 50% or less at fault, damages are reduced by their fault percentage.
    • Pedestrians found to be 51% or more at fault cannot recover damages.
  • California and New York’s Approach:
    • Pedestrians partially at fault can still receive compensation, reduced by their fault percentage.
    • This allows for some recovery even if the pedestrian contributed to the accident.
  • Tips for Navigating Comparative Negligence:
    1. Seek immediate medical attention post-accident.
    2. Collect evidence (photos, witness statements).
    3. Consult with a pedestrian accident lawyer experienced in personal injury cases.
    4. Be transparent about your actions and level of fault during the incident.

Understanding these nuances is crucial for both pedestrians and drivers involved in accidents. Each state’s specific laws can significantly impact the legal and financial outcomes of the parties involved.

Legal and Financial Implications for At-Fault Pedestrians

Navigating the aftermath of a pedestrian accident where the pedestrian is at fault involves a series of legal and financial steps. Here’s a breakdown to understand the implications better:

  • Legal Counseling and Negotiations:
    • Both parties require legal counseling to navigate the complexities of the situation.
    • Negotiating with insurance adjusters is crucial. If the insurer’s determination seems unreasonable, options like mediation, arbitration, or filing a lawsuit might be necessary.
  • Understanding State-specific Laws:
    • In Nevada, pedestrians must adhere to traffic laws, including using crosswalks and avoiding prohibited areas.
    • California determines fault based on negligence, requiring motorists to exercise due care. Violating a pedestrian’s right-of-way presumes driver negligence.
  • Consequences of Violations:
    • Driving under the influence and hitting a pedestrian in Nevada could lead to DUI charges, with penalties ranging from fines to prison time, depending on the severity and previous convictions.
    • Reckless driving causing injury or death, and hit-and-run incidents carry severe penalties, including jail time, fines, and possible suspension or revocation of the driver’s license.

These steps and consequences highlight the importance of understanding legal responsibilities and the potential financial and legal repercussions for at-fault pedestrians.


Through a detailed exploration of pedestrian responsibilities, scenarios of fault, and the intricate legal framework surrounding traffic accidents involving pedestrians, this guide underscores the critical nature of adhering to traffic laws and safety protocols for both pedestrians and drivers. It has elaborately dissected the determining factors of fault and liability, delving into how comparative negligence influences the outcome of legal proceedings and the nuanced roles that attorneys play in advocating for fair compensation. By emphasizing the shared responsibilities on the road, the article brings to light the essential tactics to minimize accidents and the subsequent legal and financial repercussions for those found at fault.

Understanding the broader implications of pedestrian accidents on legal, societal, and personal levels, this guide signifies the importance of cooperation and awareness among all road users. It highlights the significance of each action taken by pedestrians and drivers, illustrating how such behaviors can lead to multi-faceted consequences within the realms of law and safety. As society progresses towards a more conscientious approach to road safety, this guide serves as a foundational piece to inform, educate, and guide individuals in navigating the complex landscape of pedestrian accidents, fostering a safer environment for all.


Can your car get damaged if you hit a pedestrian?

Yes, hitting a pedestrian can result in damage to your car, and it may also cause injuries to yourself or any passengers. If the pedestrian is responsible for the accident, you may be able to claim compensation for the damages incurred.

What types of injuries do pedestrians sustain in accidents?

Pedestrians involved in accidents often suffer from broken bones and fractures, particularly in the hands, wrists, arms, shoulders, legs, and back. Severe accidents can lead to serious compound fractures, where the bone breaks and pierces through the skin.

What are the consequences if a pedestrian is at fault for an accident in the UK?

If a pedestrian in the UK is found to be at fault for causing an accident that results in injury to a driver, they can be held accountable for damages. This might include claims for personal injury, financial losses, and vehicle damage. However, pursuing such claims may not always be practical or worthwhile.

What should you do if you hit a pedestrian in South Africa?

In South Africa, if you hit a pedestrian or cyclist, you must adhere to the duties outlined in Section 61 of the National Road Traffic Act. This includes immediately stopping the vehicle and reporting the accident to the authorities.

Scroll to Top